Can Fitness Trackers Make You Feel Worse? The Nocebo Effect

Have you heard of the nocebo effect? Where expecting a bad outcome can bring about the experience of a bad outcome. Which Zahrt et al. (2023) found can come from wearable devices - those very devices we’re all wearing supposedly to increase our health?

​(Read this post on the blog instead)​

In one study, when participants were told they had poor sleep or good sleep, it affected their actual cognitive performance accordingly.

In another study, when participants were given deflated step counts that told them they hadn’t achieved enough movement, they had real physiological, psychological and behavioural impacts - increased blood pressure and heart rate, more unhealthy eating, and reduced mental health.

Now in these studies, it could be argued the conclusions are about inaccuracy or the way these scores are reported. As, conversely, inflated or accurate scores can enhance performance.

So couldn’t that be a good thing? Perhaps.

When it comes to tracking our health, on the surface it seems good - seeing our steps or our score, giving us motivation boost.

But what if you do have a bad sleep?

What if you have kids, an illness, or stress that you can't control and so your poor sleep score is accurate. When you check it that morning... have you just inadvertently locked in decreased cognitive function that day?

In both the positive and negative effects of wearable trackers - the placebo or the nocebo effect - it’s still two sides of the same coin: the outsourcing of our bodily awareness. We’re giving apps the power to dictate whether we feel good or bad that day.

We can see clearly that believing you had good sleep or took enough steps can positively affect physical and mental health. Call it the placebo effect or the power of positive thinking - but we know our minds can shape our experience, our behaviour, and even our literal health.

So why not use that power with intention?

We love our data. It feels more concrete than, say, affirmations or visualisation. It's easier to slap on a wrist band than it is to show up every day and cultivate our mindset.

But that's exactly why too much tracking might just be the worst thing we can do; it's much harder for us to counteract the "hard data" in front of us with mindset alone. It becomes an authoritative truth. And so a ceiling we mentally don't allow ourselves to surpass.

But it doesn’t have to be.

If we really want to shift our health outcomes, and feel truly better - not just keep a score - then maybe it’s time we ditch the trackers, and put ourselves back in charge of our bodies instead.

What do you think?


In our app My Yoga Timer we do have tracking and a streak counter. This sort of reward is meant to keep you motivated - we have also added the ability to turn off the streak tracker, because many people have said it does the opposite

And I sometimes wonder, should we just remove it completely?

Let us know - does tracking fitness or streaks help you? Or do the opposite?

Reply to this email and let us know, or add your thoughts in the comments on the blog post. We'd love to hear what you think!

Jess & Ollie, Creators of My Yoga Timer

My Yoga Timer | Edge Effect Media

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Thrive & Flow

Supporting your goals by making movement easy. Yoga, breathwork and meditation for movement breaks, stress relief and everyday wellbeing.